In chapter eight of The Darkening Age: The Christian Destruction of the Classical World, Catherine Nixey wrote:
Further south, the firebrand preacher John Chrysostom—John ‚Goldenmouth’—weighed in. This man was so charismatic that crowds of Christians would pack into Antioch’s Great Church to hear him speak, his eyes flashing, then leave as soon as he was finished, ‚as if‘, he observed, with a distinct want of monkish humility, ‚I were a concert performance.‘ Chrysostom was nothing if not zealous.
Hearing that Phoenicia was still ’suffering from the madness of the demons‘ rites‘, he sent violent bands of monks, funded by the faithful women in his congregation, to destroy the shrines in the area. ‚Thus,‘ concludes the historian Theodoret, ‚the remaining shrines of the demons were utterly destroyed.‘ A papyrus fragment shows Bishop Theophilus standing triumphantly over an image of Serapis, Bible in hand, while on the right-hand side monks can be seen attacking the temple. St Benedict, St Martin, St John Chrysostom; the men leading these campaigns of violence were not embarrassing eccentrics but men at the very heart of the Church.
Augustine evidently assumed his congregants would be taking part in the violence—and implied that they were right to do so: throwing down temples, idols and groves was, he said, no less than ‚clear proof of our not honouring, but rather abhorring, these things‘. Such destruction, he reminded his flock, was the express commandment of God. In AD 401, Augustine told Christians in Carthage to smash pagan objects because, he said, that was what God wanted and commanded. It has been said that sixty died in riots inflamed by this burst of oratorical fire. A little earlier a congregation of Augustine’s, eager to sack the temples of Carthage, had started reciting Psalm 83. ‚Let them be humiliated and be downcast forever,‘ they chanted with grim significance. ‚Let them perish in disgrace.‘
It is obvious that this violence was not only one’s Christian duty; it was also, for many; a thoroughly enjoyable way to spend an afternoon. Those carrying out the attacks sang as they smashed the ancient marble and roared with laughter as they destroyed statues. In Alexandria, ‚idolatrous‘ images were taken from private houses and baths, then burned and mutilated in a jubilant public demonstration. Once the assault was complete, the Christians ‚all went off, praising God for the destruction of such error of demons and idolatry‘.
Broken statues themselves were another cause for hilarity; their fragmented remains an occasion for ‚laughter and scorn‘.